At 127 North Madison Avenue in Playhouse Village, a new five-story building called The Madison has 49 condominiums over subterranean parking, a central courtyard, a rooftop deck, an amphitheater and a putting green. Prices start at $1.5 million and go up to $2.7 million. In Bungalow Heaven, the Craftsman neighborhood in northeast Pasadena, homes of all types closed at a median of roughly $1.46 million over the three months through October.
The prices are close, but buying in each place is a different experience. In Bungalow Heaven, buyers compete with each other for a handful of houses. In the central condo blocks, sellers compete for buyers, and new construction keeps adding to their number. If you're deciding where to spend about $1.5 million in Pasadena, the type of home is only half the choice. The other half is which side of the negotiation you'll be on.
Four listings in Pasadena's first landmark district
Bungalow Heaven was Pasadena's first historic landmark district, and its Arts and Crafts-era houses draw crowds whenever they open their doors. The Pasadena Star-News reported that the 35th annual Bungalow Heaven Home Tour came back on April 26, 2026, with eight historic bungalows open to visitors after the previous year's tour was postponed.
Buying one is much harder than touring one. Realtor.com counted just four active listings in Bungalow Heaven in October 2026, down 60% from a year earlier. Redfin's figures for the three months through October show a median sale price of $1,464,299, up 20.8% year over year, a median of 29 days on market, and homes of all types closing at 107% of list price. Realtor.com's October snapshot puts the neighborhood's median sold price at $1.45 million with 36 days on market.
Here's what that ratio means in dollars. At 107% of list, a home asking about $1.37 million closes near the $1.46 million median, so the winning buyer pays roughly $95,000 above the asking price. The wider 91104 ZIP code shows the same pattern at a slightly cooler pace. Its median sale price over the three months through October was $1,409,278, up 11.8% year over year, with 39 days on market and a 104.3% sale-to-list ratio.
Put the four listings beside the 10 Bungalow Heaven sales Redfin counted in October, and the neighborhood was selling homes faster than new ones were coming to market. A buyer in 91104 this fall should expect the asking price to be where the bidding starts.
The Madison and the new supply in central Pasadena
The central blocks are changing quickly. The Madison is the largest single batch of new condos to open in Pasadena in recent years, as Urbanize LA reported when all 49 units went on sale in August. The units range from 1,036 to 1,856 square feet, so the $1.5 million entry price works out to about $1,450 per square foot for the smallest plan. The builder, Toledo Homes, lists The Madison as in pre-sale with an estimated completion in December 2026.
The Madison is part of a longer run of projects. Toledo Homes lists One Seventy Eight Euclid, its 42-condo building at 178 South Euclid Avenue with ground-floor retail, as completed and sold out. The same builder lists 17 units at 139 South Oak Knoll Avenue with sales in progress. Urbanize LA reported in February that revised plans for 83 North Lake Avenue call for one building with 54 residential units. Earlier this year, The Real Deal reported that the Pasadena City Council denied an appeal against K27 Capital's 46-unit project at 511 South Oak Knoll Avenue, though more design review remained before construction.
The Real Deal put the city's housing target at 9,429 new units by 2029. For a condo buyer, the list of buildings in the pipeline means more choice in the central blocks over the next few years.
Resale condos around the new buildings
New buildings change the math for owners of existing condos nearby. A resale unit down the street now competes with a brand-new building that has a rooftop deck and a sales team. The October numbers point the same way.
In the Playhouse District, Realtor.com's October 2026 snapshot shows 42 active listings, up 63.64% from a year earlier. The median sold price was $737,500, and homes took a median of 76 days to sell. That median is less than half The Madison's starting price, so resale buyers in the same district are shopping a very different price range from the new building.
The 91101 ZIP code, which covers much of central Pasadena, tells a similar story. Realtor.com counted 85 active listings there in October, up 18.52% year over year, with a median of 74 days on market for listings. Redfin's three months through October show a median sale price of $772,854, down 2.7% year over year, and a median of 59 days on market, 12 days longer than a year earlier. Homes closed at 98.3% of list, down 2.9 points from a year earlier. At that ratio, a unit listed at $775,000 closes about $13,000 under asking. In Bungalow Heaven, the typical buyer pays about $95,000 over.
The citywide condo numbers match. HelloCondo's September 2026 report on Pasadena condos showed 59 new listings, up 68.57% year over year, while sales fell 7.5% to 37 and average days on market reached 101. When new listings grow that much faster than sales, condos stay on the market longer and buyers have more time.
Sales have not stopped. Redfin counted 47 closed sales in 91101 in October, up 21.2% from a year earlier. Condos are still selling, but buyers set more of the pace and more of the terms.
How each market changes your offer
For the city as a whole, Redfin's three months through October show a median sale price of $1,201,664, with a median of 47 days on market and a 101.6% sale-to-list ratio. That average mixes two different markets, and a buyer at $1.5 million will feel which one they're in from the first showing.
In Bungalow Heaven and the rest of 91104, the strength of an offer depends on things a seller can rely on: a clean contract, a timeline that suits the seller, and a price set with closings near 104% to 107% of list in mind. With four active listings in October, a buyer may wait weeks for the right house and then face a short window to decide. The work is in preparing before the listing appears: having inspections lined up, financing settled, and a firm idea of what that particular bungalow is worth to you.
In the central condo blocks, waiting is cheaper. A buyer looking at a Playhouse District resale that has sat for 76 days is in a different conversation than a buyer bidding on a bungalow listed for a week. For new construction like The Madison, the useful questions are about the building: the estimated completion date, what is included in each finish level, and how the unit compares with the larger plans at the top of the $2.7 million range.
Both markets reward design judgment. A Craftsman bungalow may need work that a buyer has to price in before going over asking. A new condo is delivered finished, so the choice comes down to floor plan, light and outdoor space. Our Pasadena Craftsman buyer's guide covers the bungalow side, and our earlier look at Pasadena condo living covers daily life in the central blocks.
Questions buyers ask about this split
When is The Madison expected to be finished? Toledo Homes lists an estimated completion of December 2026. Until move-ins begin, buyers are purchasing in pre-sale.
What else is planned in central Pasadena? The projects listed above are 17 units at 139 South Oak Knoll Avenue, a 54-unit project at 83 North Lake Avenue, and K27 Capital's 46 units at 511 South Oak Knoll Avenue.
Is Bungalow Heaven always this tight? In October 2026, active listings were down 60% from the year before, to four. Over the same three months, homes there closed at a median of 29 days on market. You can find more context on the city on our Pasadena neighborhood page.
If you're weighing a Bungalow Heaven bungalow against a new condo at The Madison, LA Realty Concierge can walk both with you, compare the October numbers for each, and help you build an offer that fits the market you choose, whether that's a fast bid on a bungalow or a negotiated condo purchase. Schedule Your Concierge Consultation.